I don't mind the pedophilia in Mushoku, but the polygyny makes it unwatchable

I don't mind the pedophilia in Mushoku, but the polygyny makes it unwatchable.

polygyny makes it unwatchable.

Why?

infidelity offends me

it removes the suspension of disbelief. Polygyny simply doesn't work, a woman wouldn't be satisfied just with 1/3rd or less of the attention any other woman in the world with a man gets.(and same in reverse with men) people would rather be alone than live in such a shitty living situation.

post tits or gtfo

I don't like polygymy not for being a bad thing itself but i can't belive someone living with 3 womens and not getting tired since they act like growth up children.

Why is Roxy such a bitch? she ruined the whole show

polygyny

What about polyandry?

It's isekai fiction so i don't mind, it's a very common trope in this genre. Harem is a big classic. Also Mushoku is a bigger story than just "polygyny"

You mean man-god
The only reason Rudy ended up with Sylphie is because of careful manipulation, Roxy is his fated lover

But no matter what gods do, they cannot change the simple fact that man will stick his willy into a MIGGER

This stuff was completely normal in our own world what makes you think it wouldn't work in a fictional one

Sylphie getting the short end of the stick and being endlessly happy and forgiving with being shit on was actually compelling to read.

Polygyny simply doesn't work, a woman wouldn't be satisfied just with 1/3rd or less of the attention any other woman in the world with a man gets

If that one third attention is coming from a blonde chad, it’s worth more than that of a 1000 average men.

polygyny

You can't even spell polygamy.

endlessly happy and forgiving

That's not true, she boots him in the Oldeus timeline. The fact is that Rudeus worked for and deserves his wives and they owe him sex.

Polygyny is a type of polygamy, retard.
Polygyny = Multiple Women
Polyandry = Multiple Men

Are there only two redundancy novels out yet?

I can understand Sylphie accepting Roxy. She is responsible for growing up the Rudeus that left his home and utmostly saved her from the bullying and teached her magic.
Now I can't understand her accepting Eris, the woman who shattered Rudeus confidence. I know there are some circunstances happening when she returns end up helping her case, but I'm going for the "woman logic" here.

"Polygyny" is a shibboleth. No native speaker uses this extremely low frequency word. Polyandry is also not a normal cultural concept in any English speaking country. You are a third-world bitch. Eat shit and die.

encounters word he doesn't recognize, calls other poster brown

Smartest Anon Babblekike

third one will be out in june

If Sylphie was a good wife then Rudeus wouldn't need two more

I never take the opinion of anyone who unironically uses the term pedophilia, pedophile, etc. seriously.
If your post contains that word and it is not actively insulting somebody else who also used it, because they used it, your post means about as much to me as a "Good Morning Saar"
That being said, Sylphie is the best girl, and FUCK THE MAN GOD, and FUCK GEESE
I am Orsted Inc.'s most loyal salaryman.

It is normal in cultures where women are considered less than men

b b but rich men had multiple women

Generally still one wife and many concubines.

Prove you're not a thirdie by cursing Indra in your native tongue.

The story already makes it unwatchable. It is bad even by light novel standards

You don't read light novels.

It worked in many parts of the world for many years

What are you fucking talking about nigger? Polygyny is the way of the world. 10% of the men getting 90% of the pussy and all that. It's simply that religion and the institution of marriage somewhat resisted that natural order by punishing and ostracizing thots. Now that women have freedom, they revert to old ways, chasing unavailable men.

Rudy wins his fights after Orsted, the fuck are you on about nigger?

You're talking to an Indian. He won't understand if you don't call him bich blasterd.

Reading the novel convinced me that three women are too much and two works best. Eris is nothing but a hanger-on that acts more like Rudy's bodyguard than a wife. She only joins the polycule due to forgone obligation.

Orsted constantly bails him out and takes away his agency. Turning your MC into a subservient lackey sucks ass.

whorexy doesn't deserve marriage

based

He's just his boss. Most of Rudy's fights happens without Orsted's help. Like Auber and Alek, or the Temple Knights.

Roxy and Sylphy help and love each other, they aren't just Rudy's token wives. They literally end up as each other's life partners in a world where they didn't end up with Rudy.

it removes the suspension of disbelief

This.

Broken moral compass

You break your moral compass each time you come on this website.

I really like their dynamic

Maybe from the perspective of a genetic dead end like yourself, polygyny seems unsustainable. In reality, Chinese Emperors had concubines somewhere in the range of hundreds to even thousands.

Yuri trannies are all misandrists that hate any positive depiction of the animus, hence their hatred of "self-inserts" (which is just a spiteful slur).

Polygyny is based when done properly. I've heard about Wheel of Time and from what I've heard it seems it shares a surprising amount of similarities with MT. Is this true? Any MT bros that read WoT?

You are dysgenic white trash, kys.

you're such a low iq retard, you are incapable of understanding the mindset, philosophies and lifestyles of people in a middle-ages pre-industrialisation, zero social safety net system.

Women back then, unless they were in a rich family, had few prospects, and many had very limited pools for which a mate could be found. They weren't getting simped on by hundreds of thirsty indians on Instagram and didn't have access to the pictures of every attractive man on earth at whim.

Their egos were minimal and there were plenty of scenarios where at least 50% of the female populace would have zero problem being one of multiple wives. Caste based societies in general saw such things as normal.

It was literally only the catholic faith blowing up that normalised the concept of monogamy as a law. You don't know human nature, or history, yet you're mouthing off in here on both subjects? know your limits retard.

Mushokufags are the most insecure people on this website, the fact that they keep responding to these bait threads every single time instead of simply ignoring them or owning it up like gatarifags means that we will have shitty threads like this being made for a long time.

In scenarios like this, women might be inclined to forgive alot, if they are emotionally compatible with the other would-be wives. Social networks were very limited back then, having women around you, your own age, who you can relate with and talk to anytime, would make your overall happiness pretty good, assuming you all figure out a decent schedule to spend time with the one husband you share that is.

bro has never read history.

So Rudy gets Eris, Roxy, and Elf?
Lucky

i would definitely want to fuck both of them

it's a selfinsert cope haremshit anime, retard
faggots like you who try to apply 3DPD logic to anime should be executed.
You're ruining this board and hating on anime stapples like a fucking tourist.

there was no pedo stuff in WoT, but as a big fan of those books, their polygamist marriage was rather short lived and they were all of them, cowboying around the world most of the time so a stable homelife scenario never happened at all.

Rand and his 3 sexy bitches (amazons abomination-fanfiction doesnt count at all) rarely were all in the same city at the same time in the last half of the series. Aviendha is best girl btw.

i dont think the Romans were polygamous. of course most societies also had whores and sexual slavery.
the whole point of polygamy is sexual variety. and, yeah, a man can love more than one woman. because for men, love and lust are not that different.

i really dont think it was as common as you think, even in pre-Christian societies. im not saying it didnt happen. it has happened in modern times. but it can be destabilizing if a small number of men have all the wives.
one of the benefits of monogamy is more people can get married.

Yeah, though

Roxy always feels like a "trophy wife" despite Rudy trying to tell her otherwise

He never got to bang tsundere loli Eris, which was when she was the hottest.

Sylphy isn't green anymore (ruins the RGB color scheme, a great loss to gamers)

I havent read the books, but Roxy seems uncomfortable with Rudys admiration in the show. she feels like the inferior mage and doesnt understand why he adores her so much.
that was how i perceived it. that and being second wife might make her feel less worthy.
also, consider, sylphie has a snow white bush. yeah its not green but its probably really nice.

Lol, lmao even.
IRL Harems were fucking political messes between the girls to gain influence over an important political figure. None of the sweet 'lets all share him' kind of deal we like in fiction.

this whole show is unwatchable
it's the worst isekai fantasy slop ever created
even overlord is better than this

older eris is also very good though

I wouldn't mind the polygamy wasn't handled so terribly. It's just hand-waved away.
It's better in the LN, mind you, but still shitty.

i love MT so much and no one is going to change my mind.

I loved the polygyny in Mushoku, but the pedophilia makes it unwatchable
Seriously, "harem, but ACTUALLY a harem" is incredibly rare, in anime at least

theres no pedophilia. rusy never touches a girl younger than him in a prurient matter.

mentally he is

no. hes a child when hes reborn. he cant very well fuck adults as a 9 year old.
rudy is very lucky to have a run at jailbait twice, and hes a perfect gentleman about it. most of the time.

i was just parroting the OP, rudy is just cringe. go fight someone else on this, soldier.

No it fucking wasn't. Harems were basically battlefields in all but name. Constant power struggles and backstage deals. Hell harem was one of the bigger contributor to downfall of ottomans. There simply hasn't been this kind of harem and that's why it ruins the whole tone.

So now that the dust has settled, can we all agree that Rifujin is better than Tolkien, Lewis, Le Guin, Martin, Jordan, Wolfe, Moorcock, Jacques, Mark Lawrence, Sanderson and Togashi.

Zoomies can't handle peak. It makes them seethe when they have to think for more than two seconds.

its not a harem
a harem implies concubines
rudy is married to the girls

i think of him as a kind of soul successor to heinlein
not sci-fi obviously but the story is about a strong and unique guy who forges his own path, is true to his friends, fucks who he wants to fuck, marries who he wants to marry, doesnt quit, and only takes shit from his boss. and his boss is a seriously fucking meretricious person himself.

Overlord is retarded in comparison, MT is amongst the very best isekais ever and you're retarded to not see that.

the black company one is also another fantastic one. And of course why cant i pickup girls in the dungeon is a great one.

There was an entire society of people in America practicing polygyny, and some who still do, called Mormonism, you fucking idiots.

I will rep Overlord till the day I die, but you're comparing it to something that's way out of its league. MT is a timless classic. The problem is most of you are anime onlies and have only seen a small part of the story. A story which follows this guy from rock bottom to his death. Wait till you read/watch the whole thing before you say shit like that.

Joseph Smith was killed by a seething moralfag mob for it though