What makes a scene "over-animated"?

What makes a scene "over-animated"?

When I don’t like it

girls can be flamboyant

anything more than flapping mouths is forced animation

True animation

Succinct and purposeful. It never moves "just to move", it moves to make a point, tell a story, or enhances actions and purpose. The cognition, internal working, and acting is a key role.

Forced animation/over-animation

Moves just to move. Is unconvincing and poorly-conceived by very nature. Lacks both a storyteller's voice or a craftsman's wit.

Dishonest animation

Basically, it's the same as forced animation, except it achieves, on some level, either storytelling or craftsmanship, but never both. Neither amateur, nor professional.

Thank you Anon Babble

Wasn't made in Powerpoint

tiktok

adhd

reddit

netflix

irl le meme girls

oversaturating

irritating

These are some of the things that came into my mind while watching this.

I already forgot what's this show is even called. That's how forgettable it truly was.

What makes a scene "over-animated"?

The universal consensus of hipster niggerweeb anime theoreticians

It sounds like you have ADHD yourself. You should just focus on the scene.

When it looks like this

Too many frames.

do they need an excuse to animate a cute girl making pouty faces?

When the spike in frames and additional or otherwise larger movements comes with no apparent purpose for the scene that's happening in its context compared to the rest of the story. Naomi pointing a gun at the jester in an earlier episode had a frame spike that could contribute to the drama and the jester's inhuman movements to dodge bullets, but this scene had no proper setup or direction for how casually and hastily Naomi was revealing herself to not be human (only androids could survive in that environment).

coworkers start talking about video games face

would this be considered overly directed?

This looks great. Overanimated would be the wan pies scenes animated by shartzard

Holy fuck, is that what spongebob has become?

When Naotoshi Shida animates it

When the "animated" part is actually a whacky camera

American humor everyone
Aside from their mouths looking so retarded I think this looks fine. Better than whatever the fuck gear 5 is doing on screen honestly.

This

when you can tell their mindset is, "more things being animated means better animation" like thinking a song with more notes or instruments automatically makes it good music

You mean when Bincent Chainsaw or whatever that e-celeb's name is animates it

I think the only thing weird is how the black haired girl reacts to taking off the suit at first. Everything else seems normal to me. I also like how the white haird lady does the 'thats me' motion so maybe I am biased with this example.
I can't tell what is going on in the webm. There's no way modern One Piece is this wild, is it? Just a bad example?

forced animation

over animated

spending "budget" on one scene

kill yourself

HE SAY YOU BRADE RUNNA

How is anyone supposed to take Anon Babble animation discussion seriously when every video has to be compressed enough to fit into a 90s fmv game

I wish more anime looked like Gohands shows

both of them. Chansard is a blatant tryhard whose scenes almost always end up incomprehensible. poor timing, poor framing, all style / no substance
Shida's mdoern animations are just gross to look at, even though you can tell he's fundamentally talented. I mean, decades ago the guy did that kid Goku VS Kuririn scene that everyone loves, now he's doing picrelated (I say now, but this shit is a decade old too)

Do the japs even like the faggot chansard cuts? or do they only care about the underage troon faggot blue-pink hair retards with 0.5 secs of attention span since they the shout the loudest.
God I wish more of them killed themself.

Does the idea of a retard with a 0.5 secs of attention span who shouts loudly remind you of anyone?

I actually like this one.
I think it is fun.
I appreciate the subtle movements even if it is exaggerated

This scene makes the characters feel like real girls. So of course Anon Babble hates it.
Case in point.

and here's Chansard's work. if you can figure out what's going on, please let me know

Chansard is also bad yes, the poster child of all the problems that many younger animators (in particular foreign ones for some reason) have, it's all motion for the sake of motion, there's no soul behind it and the readability of their cuts is awful. It could be somewhat excused if they were like some of the webgen animators, who, while making unreadable cuts, were still trying to innovate with their styles. Chansard and other animators of his kind are not doing that however, they are all just copies of each other, it's an ouroboros creative death.

What makes Chansard extra annoying in my mind though is that he's been doing key animation for something like 5 years and he just refuses to change. I like to compare him to Hiroto Nagata, when he first started catching people's attention in 2021, it was also hard to discern what was happening in his cuts, but you know what's the difference? Nagata listened to the criticism, look at his stuff today, his style is still there but now you can actually tell what the fuck is going on, it looks great. Chansard on the other hand just keeps doing the same thing over and over, the same lack of understanding what the real purpose of movement in animation is, the same unreadable bullshit.

Shida on the other hand is a different case in my mind. I don't think he's like Chansard, I think Shida actually understands animation in a way Chansard never could, every now and then he'll even create something that I genuinely like (see this sakugabooru.com/post/show/150992). My problem is that for every good cut he makes, there's like 5 where he seems to over commit to a few signature elements of his style, his timing and spacing are way too regular, it makes a lot of the movement (specially character animation) feel uncanny. His obsession for animating on 1s is kinda cool in moderation, but his usual stuff is not using it in moderation.

I'd take Shida before Chansard, but I dislike both, both can be bad.
Sorry for the rant anon

it's simple, it's a faggot attention-seeking

Speaking of over-worked, I had a refreshing two weeks. I didn't know why my mood was so good and why my blood pressure was at healthy levels again.

And then Anon Babble came back and the same old retards rushed back to make the same old fucking bait threads.
Yare yare...趣味ねぇのか?まったくもう

Naotoshi Shida is great. I just wish he worked on anime that aren't shit.

When they crank up the 3D

It insists upon itself.

Anything animated by Vincent cucksword

I genuinely have no idea what’s going on in most of his scenes. I feel like the guy takes a shit load of drugs before animating anything.

when theres 50000 frames of just someone chewing something

if you can figure out what's going on,

are there people that cant follow simple animation?

this is kino

simple

Nigger, the characters are sliding around half way through that video and any sense of motion or positioning is lost. To pretend like that is easy to follow or even competent animation is a bold faced LIE. It looks like someone’s schizo dream that was animated. No sense of pace or anything.

every time I see something from this guy I feel like he forgot to animate some scenes

It's expressionist animation you swine.
Not everything has to be a rote imitation of real movement.

single handedly ruined the one piss anime
now he's ruining rezero

It makes a retard pretending it's not from Anon Babble mad.

This is barely animated. It just has a lot of screen wobble. The actual amount of animation in the frames is 80's level.
I'd rather flashing bullshit lights they banned for causing seizures than this motion sickness bait too.

not to suck anon's dick but this is pretty much the best, most succinct way of putting it. yes, things like "storyteller's voice" or "craftsman's wit" are admittedly subjective at best and unhelpful abstractions at worst, but anyone with an actual eye for art can distinguish stuff like this, silly as it may sound.

the girls have massive shoulders and necks, looking distinctly mannish.

rather than simple, most shots in that clip are misleading. lots of focus and emphasis on elements that ultimately are pointless and not noteworthy or important at all, while also leaving out information that is critical for understanding.
it's not simple, nor is it complex; it's incoherent.

I think what a lot of people here forget is a show can be barely animated but still be dishonest and have forced soul. See: Eizouken

GODhands

The entire gear 5 transformation was so bad but a perfect example. Toei piece has been an absolute disaster

This is bad directing and misuse of CGI. "Forced animation" could have helped these scenes, if anything.