Fuck modern anime

Fuck modern anime

why is our resident Anon Babble crossboarder suddenly so uppity?

vgh... they don't make em like they used too...

Canada looks nothing like either of those.

blame the director
retard.

Modern one is better, actually.

I preferred this scene in the book

zoomers and apologists will defend modern anime with the weakest arguments and dumbest fallacies
The truth is right in front of your eyes, anime -for the most part- used to look better

inb4 cherry pick shitty low budget anime from the 80s

Cell animation will return sooner or later.

why does it thoroughly suck the soul out of it?

holy shit this is like watching some super long running cartoon or anime, think simpsons or detective conan
top is well but simple a animation, the girl every much behaving like a child of her time would or should, well behaved and respectful
bottom is what would happen if you put a hyper active (autistic) zoomer child into an old scenario like this, her behaving like the retard she is, the animation of it all fit to suit said character change, being equally obnoxious and annoying to look at
i'm not even nostalgic for this, no idea what this is to begin with, but bottom looks horrendously terrible

Cell animation

comparing motherfucking Isao Takahata to random seasonal anime

active (autistic)

Autists tends to be shy retardo kun, some of them kinda behave quirky after gaining some trust or when they aren't interacting with others.

entire post destroyed

Which of the two scenes is more faithful to the original work?

The top one is the original

which of these two is more faithful to the original work at the top?

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

Canada's a big place. It looks like lots of things. Or were you just confused by the lack of igloos, like a typical ignorant mutt?

You genuinely have to be a retard to prefer the top one

I mean the books

The book, you illiterate mongoloids.

autism + adhd is hyperactive and common

You have to eat a steaming pile of shit and say you love it or else you're Anon Babble

the remake is a bit more true to the idea that she's just talking his ear off without him really being able to react, but the way it's presented isn't in line with the tone and style of the book either.

Do you guys watch anime just to complain? I mean you know that every anime is going to be digital and you have a problem with digital anime in general even if some of the complaints about modern anime are valid. What is the point of watching something you know you will hate? If would be one thing if you found things you liked in modern anime but it's always just complaining and hating everything.

bottom one is better

The absolute state of Anon Babble.

Seems good to me. Maybe a tad too bright.

You must be fun at parties always screaming and insulting people for being mildly wrong about something you pretend to know about

in other words its made up garbage animated in a way that zoomer/alpha brainrotten children are able to stay awake
almost like adapting old material like this is a bad idea for 2025 because the audience is too damn retarded to appreciate it

I hope you're not implying that people like OP would be fun at parties. They're the ones who would be complaining about the music playing and wanting to play Queen instead.

Have you tried not being retarded?

About what I expect from a thread like this.

Good. Pre-00 tards and retrofags should get the rope.

Holy buzzwords, I can guarantee you never watched the original or read the books.

holy shit what the fuck happened to Anon Babble?

soulless

all these contrarian troll post

its easy to forget what a shit hole Anon Babble has become, it's all "le ironic shit posting ebin troll xDD" garbage (that used to be a bannable offense) now days.

mildly wrong

But you were fully wrong, mister.

She's a motormouth but not as physically obnoxious.
The Miyazaki adaptation makes her too reserved and respectful and 'perfect'.
The second makes her more extreme, but gets you the same feeling of her dumping on the man more. I think it could have been cut back some. She's too 'genki'.
Most disingenuous post of the day.

Normalnigger paradise now

Excuse me, it was Takahata, not Miyazaki.

I don't think the problem is digital.

cell animation is the worst, lighting was garbage. money's the problem now.

the "miyazaki" one has her present herself that way because she's meeting her new father, dork. she still lets her true nature show in how she won't stop talking, though.

money's the problem now.

absolute brainlet moment

So, her being so energetic is an interpretation of the new adaptation.

Not enough gatekeeping

OP here (first reply).

complaining about the music playing and wanting to play Queen instead.

Nah lol, wtf? Whatever helps you cope though.

It's one of the problems leading to people to complain. Even if the new anime was a perfect adaptation of the book it would be something people pointed to. That and how it's "different from the original" because it would be different from the anime people associate it with regardless of how inaccurate it may have been. People seriously build their personalities around liking poor adaptations of things just because they're old. That may not be the case here but it's certainly something that happens. You can see a symptom of this in these posts

They made her an ADD spaz

That´s a weird pose. How can he stay on foot and avoid falling backwards?

Man that's tragic.

Bottom is significantly better if you think otherwise you are delusional

as expected. i wish people just watched the original, it's really good.

Both kind of suck

Superior Japanese anatomy knowledge folded 1000 times.

I don't get it, is the modern one at the top? Or are you trying to imply that it's better?

The issue is that the presentation and the reaction makes it come off as too 'saintly' and perfect, like she's an angel on Earth. And not like a little girl that won't stop rambling about what comes to mind in an overwhelming way.

but little girls are angels on earth, anon. and the way her lines are delivered, joined with matthew's body language/reaction do still make her come off as overbearing

It´s better by any metric.
The only thing, and thats up to anyone´s tastes, is the use of fish-eye lens.

zoomers can't understand subtlety

my opinion is factual because i said so!

Rugrats are rugrat.
Matt's body language and tearing up at her speech isn't an overwhelmed man, except in the emotional sense of hearing something too sad.
Her line delivery and the imagery are too 'earnest' maybe, is that the word?

subtlety

There's no subtlety in the original, the first adaptation, or the second.
They're all extremely straight forward about what they're communicating, even if they're communicating 3 different things.
Takahata's adaptation is flawed because Anne might as well have angel wings and a halo.

if you rewatched the first episode of the original anime you'd see what i mean. matthew is clearly overwhelmed in that scene.

too earnest

i think earnest is a good word for anne's overall characterization in the 70s anime. i prefer that to 2025's version of anne: a literal arm flapping retard

You niggers don't believe that, I am sorry but I can't believe that you two actually believe that or think that yourselves. You fags are being contrarian for contrarians sake.

Ok faggot, tel us why top is better, without sounding like a fucking retard.

New one looks way better.

The final years of cell had a dark filter applied on all broadcasts because of pokemon. The dvd should have been free of that filter but dvd quality was abysmal.

Bottom is more realistic. Most of the time when little girls meet new people they’re either spergs who will tell you their entire life story or hide behind something they trust and stay silent

because i like it more, art is subjective you toddler

unrelated, cells themselves block light inconsistently. looks like shit.

spend a lot of time around strange little girls do you?

If being more accurate leads to that I want inaccurate desu
Iserlohn LOGH from the 70's is far better than the garbage in Nieue Thesis

I actually agree with Anon here. A happy medium between the two versions (not quite as reserved, but also not quite as in-your-face) would be perfect.

And I think her new design is cute.

What's the problem? She's supposed to be annoying. Looks like the new one kept her being annoying.

Meanwhile at Anon Babble
youtube.com/watch?v=E28D5fTzs-Y

Nobody cares what you want though. And you could always just stick to the original instead of obsessing over new adaptations of things you claim to like and yet prefer stuff filtered through an anime studio writer trying to justify their existence while making a living off of other people's work.

Miyazaki

Takahata.

that song was painful to listen to

Top is sexually charged. I can see why it got sanitized. You shan't lust over underage girls, heathen.

His cock became diamonds so he had to adjust for his massive dong's weight.

1:1 adaptations are meaningless.

I don't even remember the show I remember the Pippi Longstocking cartoon

yeah same

Adaptations that don't capture the spirit of the original are meaningless.

Shame the anime version never got made back then.
animationobsessive.substack.com/p/the-strongest-girl-in-the-world

""'an extraordinary observer"""

it's all details only a pedo would pick up

Yup. The new version deliberately dodged the implications of that scene.

Please kill thy self

ESL third-worlders invading this board.

A child of about eleven, garbed in a very short, very tight [...] dress [...]

Hurry up

Sanitizing the lolicon underones is all great and good, but we could have make do without the fisheye lens and autistic, spastic movements.

fisheye lens is implied in the original text and symbolizes mathew cuthbert's autism

New one is better. Actually behaves like a real kid.

maybe a modern zoomer, but this anime takes place in the 1890s

they were way more feral then, an 11 year old was basically a retarded adult.

Yes, and kids were even worst back then. The mild mannered child is but a myth.

Bottom looks like the guy is wearing a wire on his coat.

Modern humans have existed for like 100k years. There is little difference in behavior or thought since then and all of it is learned behavior and not something inherent to people from the past.

Anon Babble is still mad they got outlived by Anon Babble in the latest April Fools.

This thread is full of people so far up their ass, just admit the 4:3 aspect ratio gives you ick and drop these retarded excuses why you think the remake is in any way better.

And Anon Babble lost to Anon Babble, lmao

Might be a surprise but not everyone hates new anime on principle. And it doesn't mean they hate old anime either.

bottom one is better

fisheye lens

Why do they keep doing things like this? The character designs in the new anime are better but it's ruined by retarded camera work

wrongest opinion

Counterpoint:

The original designs look dumb as hell, take off your nostalgia goggles.

the designs are both okay but the fisheye made it better

money's the problem now

Corpo Cuck Cope.

Top

Made by savant Renaissance men that knew the secrets to life.

Bottom

Made by smell hikineets that have never seen a woman.

This is why old good new bad

I like Shaft but it's cringe when other studios mimic their style.

Fuck Anne.

It's not like Shaft hasn't used fisheye but I don't think it's something people know them for really. At least as much as some other stuff.

Matthew looks better in the original.

your post only explains why new is better

You won me over, 10/10 anime

first one: creepy, this girl is mentally ill
second one: funny, this girl has ADHD

dunno what vibe they were going for and I don't remember the story so I'm just saying based on these clips

amazing

mobile user agent's aren't immediate permanent bans

Why is the new one on crack?

nigga you dumb as a doorknob

What the fuck is wrong with her forehead

The left is too obviously cheap.
Unappealing.

Yeah, the voices were better